« Your AIG Primer | Talking Points Memo Home | Witch Huntery! »

All About Lehman

03.20.09 -- 12:40PM
By Josh Marshall

It's highly technical. And it's really hard even for the experts to figure out, let alone those of us who stick to simple addition and occasional division. But with all the conversation about AIG, it's worth focusing our attention back on just how much of the current debate -- and the approach we're taking -- revolves around what happened to Lehman Brothers.

In short, last September, the Fed & Treasury 'allowed' Lehman to collapse into bankruptcy and global credit markets seized up into a global spasm that kicked the global financial crisis into really high gear. We hovered on the edge of real cataclysm and managed to work our way back to mere global crisis over a period of a couple months.

It's the Lehman experience which is behind the widespread and possibly accurate assumption that we have no choice but to pay back all the creditors and counter-parties of the big -- and probably insolvent -- banks at full dollar value.

But is the assumption correct?

There's one debate about whether it was really Lehman's collapse or the Treasury's reaction to it that caused the crisis. In as much as I'm able to understand the different arguments, this one seems pretty unconvincing.

But that's not the only question.

Lehman went under when there was much less widespread recognition of the extent of the financial crisis. And -- perhaps much more importantly -- it was done in a totally uncontrolled way. There was no effort to engineer some sort of managed receivership.

Now, a number of the smartest economists I know and whose judgments and values I really trust, think that the abyss we were looking into was so deep and vast, that it's just not worth chancing it. But there are very sharp people who make contrary arguments.

I don't have any answers on this one. But for those of us who are spectators and involuntary stakeholders in the drama, it is worth remembering just how many dollars ride on interpretations of the Lehman experience.

Recent Archives

November 29, 2009 - December 5, 2009
November 22, 2009 - November 28, 2009
November 15, 2009 - November 21, 2009
November 8, 2009 - November 14, 2009

Boehner Accuses PhRMA Of Health Reform Appeasement

John Boehner sent an angry letter to PhRMA's Billy Tauzin charging that the drug industry is appeasing Obama on health reform.

Does Tom DeLay's Quadriplegic Protesters Tale Add Up?

DeLay says quadriplegics were "dumped" in front of him at a town all -- but was he modifying a story of a protest he wasn't even present for?

Poll On Obama's Birth: If Not Here, Where?

Of 38% of respondents in a new poll who did not say Obama was born in the US, 10% said he was born in Indonesia.

Inside The '90s 'Viper Militia' Tied To Armed Anti-Obama Activist

TPMmuckraker takes a look at the 90s-era group whose most prominent defender staged the show of arms-bearing at an Obama event in Arizona.

Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address