« Just Out In Time for 100 Days | Talking Points Memo Home | Some Headlines are Golden »

A Few More Thoughts

04.30.09 -- 11:11PM
By Josh Marshall

Some stories, like the Souter retirement, mainly speak for themselves. Almost to a certainty we knew President Obama would get one or more nominations to the Court. With Souter being the first, it seems likely he'll get one or two more in his first term.

I've heard a few people mention that this represents a political opportunity for the Republicans. But for the life of me I cannot see that. Supreme Court nominations are extremely high stakes battles for partisans on both sides and each party wants to hit a nomination struggle with the most political muscle possible. President Obama has extraordinarily high personal popularity at the moment. His approval rating, while down a bit off the inaugural high, has stabilized and even tracked up a bit at a strong 60%. His party is nearing 60 seats in the senate. And the Specter party-switch, while perhaps not that significant in numerical terms, has left the senate Republican caucus deeply split and demoralized -- with one faction savoring an emasculated, tea-bag-driven ideological purity and another disgusted with the party's ultras and anxious to reenter the actual national political conversation. In other words, it's about the worst footing imaginable for senate Republicans to try to defeat or stand united against whomever Obama chooses.

The way things might play out differently is if Obama chose someone who made it look like he was fatally over-reaching -- a nominee who could galvanize a sense that Obama's extremely powerful position right now made having a credible opposition party newly necessary. Unfortunately for the GOP, though, I just don't see that happening. He hasn't shown himself prone to mistakes like that, especially not errors rooted in excessive drama or over-extension. If anything the opposite.

And the truth is that when you mix Obama's personal popularity, the progressive issue tilt that's been especially evident in polls in recent days (see the ABC/WAPO and NYT/CBS polls) Obama just has a lot of room for maneuver.

That's not to say he can simply pick whomever he wants. The center-of-gravity will be with the centrists Dems, including their newest member, Arlen Specter.

It's been suggested that maybe this is not altogether a good thing for Obama and the Democrats. Because even though it's a Supreme Court appointment, it will take away all the political oxygen from issues like health care. But I think this is an example of why the whole metaphor of political oxygen makes no sense. There's only political power, which a president is constantly in the process of gaining or losing. Actual legislation takes time, which is always finite in Congress. But this isn't a legislative battle. Besides the intense politics and a few days of hearings, it's just a vote. It's also not something like a Truth Commission, which, whatever you think of it on the merits, is profoundly divisive. Neither applies, necessarily, to a Supreme Court nomination. A Supreme Court nomination is as likely to enhance Obama's standing and political power as diminish it. Which means there's no reason -- none that I see -- to see it as a zero sum going versus other priorities like health care.

Recent Archives

November 15, 2009 - November 21, 2009
November 8, 2009 - November 14, 2009
November 1, 2009 - November 7, 2009
October 25, 2009 - October 31, 2009

Does Tom DeLay's Quadriplegic Protesters Tale Add Up?

DeLay says quadriplegics were "dumped" in front of him at a town all -- but was he modifying a story of a protest he wasn't even present for?

Inside The '90s 'Viper Militia' Tied To Armed Anti-Obama Activist

TPMmuckraker takes a look at the 90s-era group whose most prominent defender staged the show of arms-bearing at an Obama event in Arizona.

Boehner Accuses PhRMA Of Health Reform Appeasement

John Boehner sent an angry letter to PhRMA's Billy Tauzin charging that the drug industry is appeasing Obama on health reform.

Poll On Obama's Birth: If Not Here, Where?

Of 38% of respondents in a new poll who did not say Obama was born in the US, 10% said he was born in Indonesia.

Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address