« Must Read | Talking Points Memo Home | TPMtv: Sunday Show Roundup: The Tools Necessary »

Another Key Question

04.20.09 -- 8:53AM
By Josh Marshall

Swirling between Jeff Stein's blockbuster reporting on the Harman story is another question: Jeff's reporting refers to an unnamed "suspected Israeli agent", as the person Harman made the alleged deal with. Stein uses that phrase in quotations and says he was not able to determine the identity of the person. So presumably that was the description provided to him by one or more of his sources.

So my question is: what's the nationality of that person? In spy talk, an 'agent' doesn't necessarily mean a formal agent of the foreign power in question, as in a member of Israeli intelligence or a diplomat. In this context it just as likely -- in some ways, given the nature of the underlying investigation, perhaps even more likely -- means an American citizen who the investigators believed was acting as an Israeli agent -- a complicated evidentiary and legal question.

And here's where it gets sticky. The whole legal question would then depend largely, perhaps entirely, on whether that suspicion was legally provable.

To see what I mean, let's come at this from another hypothetical read of the facts. What if US citizen A comes to Harman and says, this AIPAC spy case is a total set up, an end-run around the first amendment (the argument the defenders have subsequently made, with some legal success). US citizen A asks Harman to weigh in with Gonzales (who she has lots of pull with) in exchange for help lobbying Pelosi to make her head of the intelligence committee.

To be clear, I'm not speaking to the wisdom, ethics or morality of such a deal. But if the person on the other end of the call is a US Citizen and the government can't sustain the charge that they were acting as the agent of a foreign power, it's really hard for me to see what criminal statutes that agreement would violate.

Recent Archives

November 15, 2009 - November 21, 2009
November 8, 2009 - November 14, 2009
November 1, 2009 - November 7, 2009
October 25, 2009 - October 31, 2009

Does Tom DeLay's Quadriplegic Protesters Tale Add Up?

DeLay says quadriplegics were "dumped" in front of him at a town all -- but was he modifying a story of a protest he wasn't even present for?

Boehner Accuses PhRMA Of Health Reform Appeasement

John Boehner sent an angry letter to PhRMA's Billy Tauzin charging that the drug industry is appeasing Obama on health reform.

Inside The '90s 'Viper Militia' Tied To Armed Anti-Obama Activist

TPMmuckraker takes a look at the 90s-era group whose most prominent defender staged the show of arms-bearing at an Obama event in Arizona.

Poll On Obama's Birth: If Not Here, Where?

Of 38% of respondents in a new poll who did not say Obama was born in the US, 10% said he was born in Indonesia.

Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address