« Keep a Close Eye on Them | Talking Points Memo Home | Thoughts on the Bailout Flameout »

All About Them

12.12.08 -- 10:32AM
By Josh Marshall

From TPM Reader MA ...

I think it is really important to point out that the Republicans had many alternatives to avail themselves and that they chose the worst possible one.

1) Cooperate with White House and Democratic negotiators earlier in the process

2) Negotiate in good faith with Reid following the failure of the original bill

3) Pass the original bill

4) Vote for cloture on the original bill and then vote against it.

Option (4) would have been the grown up and responsible thing to do--the bill had, probably, majority support and the consequences of not bailing out the auto industry are dire. Allowing a vote is not synonymous with acquiescing or voting in favor of the bill.

I think the fact that option (4) doesn't seem to have even been considered is indicative of the abuse of the filibuster in recent years. The filibuster is meant to be a tool to express extreme outrage, not as a device to force the threshold to passing a bill to 60 votes.
At this point, the filibuster rules have lost their relevance and should be abandoned (despite the fact that it will tie Democrat's hands in future Senate sessions when Republicans are in control.


Recent Archives

November 8, 2009 - November 14, 2009
November 1, 2009 - November 7, 2009
October 25, 2009 - October 31, 2009
October 18, 2009 - October 24, 2009

Poll On Obama's Birth: If Not Here, Where?

Of 38% of respondents in a new poll who did not say Obama was born in the US, 10% said he was born in Indonesia.

Inside The '90s 'Viper Militia' Tied To Armed Anti-Obama Activist

TPMmuckraker takes a look at the 90s-era group whose most prominent defender staged the show of arms-bearing at an Obama event in Arizona.

Does Tom DeLay's Quadriplegic Protesters Tale Add Up?

DeLay says quadriplegics were "dumped" in front of him at a town all -- but was he modifying a story of a protest he wasn't even present for?

Boehner Accuses PhRMA Of Health Reform Appeasement

John Boehner sent an angry letter to PhRMA's Billy Tauzin charging that the drug industry is appeasing Obama on health reform.

Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address