Are We Always Proud of the Ones We Love?
When Michelle Obama made her much maligned remarks about being really proud of her country for the first time in her adult life, I read the reports, cringed a little bit and then moved on, figuring she probably meant to make a more artful point and just stumbled a little.
Since she's in the news this week, I decided to listen to the soundbite. As I did, I was struck by something. I haven't been all that proud of my country either.
I love the United States and the ideals on which it was founded. But when I use the term "my country" in terms of the actions that it takes, I'm usually referring to the government. And in my lifetime, they've done some things that make me far from proud.
I was born in 1969, which means I was 18 in 1987. In my adult lifetime a sample of things my country has done includes ignoring famine and genocide, elevating Clarence Thomas to the Supreme Court, impeaching a president for lying about sex, and implementing "do as I say, not as I do" foreign and trade policies.
After 2000, it got even worse. I was going to make a list of all of the things the Bush administration has done to make me not proud but then I realized it would take far too long and would probably result in high therapy bills. Some high (low) lights: Iraq, Katrina, warrantless wiretaping, and torture.
Have I stopped loving my country? No. I love it so much I want it to live up to its potential.
But I'm not proud of my government. Hundreds of elected officials allowed my country to be hijacked by a cabal of warmongering, corporate-raiding, constitution-ignoring asshats.
Did they stand up for me? No. Did they stand up for the ideals and laws of our country? No. Did they stand up for themselves? No.
They hid under their desks and hoped nobody would notice as they continued to be beholden to the corporations and lobbyists who funded their re-election campaigns.
Then along comes a guy from Illinois who suggests that if we all work together, with our collective expertise and spirit, we can fix what ails us. Millions upon millions of people have responded with money, ideas, time, and votes.
After years of feeling like the citizens of my beloved country could do nothing while we were getting screwed, suddenly I feel hopeful again. Maybe we do haev a say in what our government does. Maybe we can stop the madness. Maybe I will feel proud of my country. We'll see.
Since she's in the news this week, I decided to listen to the soundbite. As I did, I was struck by something. I haven't been all that proud of my country either.
I love the United States and the ideals on which it was founded. But when I use the term "my country" in terms of the actions that it takes, I'm usually referring to the government. And in my lifetime, they've done some things that make me far from proud.
I was born in 1969, which means I was 18 in 1987. In my adult lifetime a sample of things my country has done includes ignoring famine and genocide, elevating Clarence Thomas to the Supreme Court, impeaching a president for lying about sex, and implementing "do as I say, not as I do" foreign and trade policies.
After 2000, it got even worse. I was going to make a list of all of the things the Bush administration has done to make me not proud but then I realized it would take far too long and would probably result in high therapy bills. Some high (low) lights: Iraq, Katrina, warrantless wiretaping, and torture.
Have I stopped loving my country? No. I love it so much I want it to live up to its potential.
But I'm not proud of my government. Hundreds of elected officials allowed my country to be hijacked by a cabal of warmongering, corporate-raiding, constitution-ignoring asshats.
Did they stand up for me? No. Did they stand up for the ideals and laws of our country? No. Did they stand up for themselves? No.
They hid under their desks and hoped nobody would notice as they continued to be beholden to the corporations and lobbyists who funded their re-election campaigns.
Then along comes a guy from Illinois who suggests that if we all work together, with our collective expertise and spirit, we can fix what ails us. Millions upon millions of people have responded with money, ideas, time, and votes.
After years of feeling like the citizens of my beloved country could do nothing while we were getting screwed, suddenly I feel hopeful again. Maybe we do haev a say in what our government does. Maybe we can stop the madness. Maybe I will feel proud of my country. We'll see.
Advertisement





Many people took Michelle's remarks in a context such as what you described. "Patriots" and "patriotism" has been dumbed down to flag pins and saying the Pledge, but not understanding the fundamental responsibilities of a "good" government.
Cindy McCain, who benefitted from being able to afford the best lawyers, could buy "justice." But the average American would have found themselves enjoying three hots and a cot at one of Arizona's most exclusive "spas" run by Maricopa County's sheriff. I guess she can afford to be proud -- proud that her money made sure her cushy lifestyle was not affected.
But I get you. Lots of us do...
June 19, 2008 8:56 PM | Reply | Permalink
I get you; big time. I was born in 1948, but I can't honestly think of anything in the last 20 years that I can really feel proud about regarding decisions coming out of our country.
I also see hope with Obama; I fear I am too hopeful, but even this day when the congress has once again capitulated to this weak and pitiful president, I wonder when it will stop.
June 19, 2008 10:15 PM | Reply | Permalink
I sometimes fear that I am too hopeful as well. But I think that Obama, for all his inspirational rhetoric, is at his core supremely pragmatic.
He knows our government is too screwed up to be fixed in a couple of grand strokes. But he also knows that unless we stop complaining about it and start taking small steps towards fixing it, nothing will get better.
I trust him. I think he trusts me back.
June 19, 2008 11:27 PM | Reply | Permalink
I think you should send your post to Michelle Obama. A sincere prose of honesty and common sense that I'm sure she'd appreciate. I know I do. Thanks.
June 20, 2008 12:57 AM | Reply | Permalink
Well done and recommended!
And this
June 20, 2008 4:05 PM | Reply | Permalink
Aw, crap! Forgot to close the blockquote! But, you get the drift, I hope.
June 20, 2008 4:06 PM | Reply | Permalink