The John McCain I Knew
For many Americans Colin Powell's trip to the UN solidified their
support for the Iraq war. I needed no such reassurance. John McCain
supported the war and so I felt comfortable and confident. In 2002, it
seemed unimaginable that John McCain would follow President Bush
blindly. Those of us who campaigned for McCain in 2000 fought on the
front lines of the first battle to stop the Bush regime.
I don't want to get into the details of the decision to support the war: the influence of September 11th and politics, the capitulation of Democratic critics, or the silencing of dissent by the media. I was a victim of and accomplice to all of that.
What I do want to talk about is the tragedy of post-2000 John McCain. This is not to say that the reality of pre-2000 McCain is as impressive or positive as I felt it was when I supported him, but instead to show how cold heartedly and cynically he betrayed those who eight years ago looked to him for leadership.
What many don't remember is that John McCain was actually the first person to fight against what has become the Bush Machine. Many, if not all, of us in that campaign understood exactly how horrible a president Bush would be, although, to be honest, we couldn't have known the true magnitude. But his lack of imagination and downright stupidity were obvious to us from the start.
The McCain 2000 campaign felt like a political insurgency against a new despot in our party (at the time, needless to say, I was a Republican). Bush was riding to power on the wings of the extremists whose influence most of us McCain folk were working to throw out of not just our party, but the entire political debate. His "agents of intolerance" line was one of the proudest moments of the process, for me at least. His campaign was fun, inspiring, fulfilling, and the most demoralizing experience I have had in politics...until I watched as McCain transformed over the ensuing years into that exact type of politician we had worked so hard against.
By 2002, the irony of McCain's "maverick" title was not apparent to me, especially as he fulfilled a seven year commitment to reform campaign finance laws with McCain-Feingold. Just before the war in 2003, I felt completely confident that McCain was not parroting administration talking points when he said: "There's no doubt in my mind that we will prevail and there's no doubt in my mind, once these people are gone, that we will be welcomed as liberators" (Hardball, March 24, 2003).
It was at this time, just preceding the Iraq war, really that McCain's transformation truly started. Perhaps to a man who had been in the Senate as long as he, the 2008 election no longer seemed that far away; or perhaps he, like many (and at times myself), was so spooked by the September 11th attacks that he turned blindly away from all that he knew and had learned about foreign policy in favor of the comfort of unthinkingly following a leader not up to the task.
Regardless, it was at this point that he began to lie to the American people and begin a six year campaign to deceive and distract the American people in order to maintain the small hope of achieving his long held dream of becoming president. Supporting the president during the 2004 campaign, McCain sounded nothing like the man whose inspiring and ultimately futile surge in New Hampshire in 2000 had almost transformed the Republican party.
Unbelievably, the history of McCain's capitulation and betrayal is clear on virtually every issue of importance over the past eight years. He has surrendered to the Republican party line, either out of political convenience or ignorance, on the Iraq War, relations with Iran, US torture policy, tax policy, judicial independence, selling out to oil companies, covering up administration lies and law breaking, and, of course, his "greatest legislative achievement," campaign finance.
I cannot put in words how thankful I am that the Democratic Party has finally nominated a man who I am willing to follow, though better informed by my past mistakes, and who, also unbelievably, has the right position on every single one of these issues, FISA notwithstanding (let's just not get into that discussion here). Senator Obama's presidential campaign pulled me out of the political confusion and darkness of being betrayed by the last leader who I believed in.
I don't want to get into the details of the decision to support the war: the influence of September 11th and politics, the capitulation of Democratic critics, or the silencing of dissent by the media. I was a victim of and accomplice to all of that.
What I do want to talk about is the tragedy of post-2000 John McCain. This is not to say that the reality of pre-2000 McCain is as impressive or positive as I felt it was when I supported him, but instead to show how cold heartedly and cynically he betrayed those who eight years ago looked to him for leadership.
What many don't remember is that John McCain was actually the first person to fight against what has become the Bush Machine. Many, if not all, of us in that campaign understood exactly how horrible a president Bush would be, although, to be honest, we couldn't have known the true magnitude. But his lack of imagination and downright stupidity were obvious to us from the start.
The McCain 2000 campaign felt like a political insurgency against a new despot in our party (at the time, needless to say, I was a Republican). Bush was riding to power on the wings of the extremists whose influence most of us McCain folk were working to throw out of not just our party, but the entire political debate. His "agents of intolerance" line was one of the proudest moments of the process, for me at least. His campaign was fun, inspiring, fulfilling, and the most demoralizing experience I have had in politics...until I watched as McCain transformed over the ensuing years into that exact type of politician we had worked so hard against.
By 2002, the irony of McCain's "maverick" title was not apparent to me, especially as he fulfilled a seven year commitment to reform campaign finance laws with McCain-Feingold. Just before the war in 2003, I felt completely confident that McCain was not parroting administration talking points when he said: "There's no doubt in my mind that we will prevail and there's no doubt in my mind, once these people are gone, that we will be welcomed as liberators" (Hardball, March 24, 2003).
It was at this time, just preceding the Iraq war, really that McCain's transformation truly started. Perhaps to a man who had been in the Senate as long as he, the 2008 election no longer seemed that far away; or perhaps he, like many (and at times myself), was so spooked by the September 11th attacks that he turned blindly away from all that he knew and had learned about foreign policy in favor of the comfort of unthinkingly following a leader not up to the task.
Regardless, it was at this point that he began to lie to the American people and begin a six year campaign to deceive and distract the American people in order to maintain the small hope of achieving his long held dream of becoming president. Supporting the president during the 2004 campaign, McCain sounded nothing like the man whose inspiring and ultimately futile surge in New Hampshire in 2000 had almost transformed the Republican party.
Unbelievably, the history of McCain's capitulation and betrayal is clear on virtually every issue of importance over the past eight years. He has surrendered to the Republican party line, either out of political convenience or ignorance, on the Iraq War, relations with Iran, US torture policy, tax policy, judicial independence, selling out to oil companies, covering up administration lies and law breaking, and, of course, his "greatest legislative achievement," campaign finance.
I cannot put in words how thankful I am that the Democratic Party has finally nominated a man who I am willing to follow, though better informed by my past mistakes, and who, also unbelievably, has the right position on every single one of these issues, FISA notwithstanding (let's just not get into that discussion here). Senator Obama's presidential campaign pulled me out of the political confusion and darkness of being betrayed by the last leader who I believed in.
Advertisement





Ben, this is well written. My only dissent is that I feel McCain really started his shift shortly after the primary in 2000, but it didn't really kick into high gear until 2003.
That's really a negligible nitpick, though. Again, excellent post, and a great chronology of the death of the "Maverick". Rec'd.
July 20, 2008 1:21 PM | Reply | Permalink
I can relate...there was a day I think before 2000, that I might have voted for John McCain. Today, I would love to see a blog '101 reasons why McCain should already be out of the race'. Just start listing off all of the absolutely moronic statements, decisions, etc. that he has made. The media pounds everything where Senator Obama is concerned and makes light or outrageous behavior, etc. by John McCain. I honestly don't understand why the man is still considered viable at all. He is not as stupid as GW Bush but he is is older and more careless... so it does start to look the same.
July 20, 2008 3:14 PM | Reply | Permalink
It turns out that McCain is much dumber than I realized all along, but what I saw that happened is exactly this:
In the 2d debate in the '04 election, John Kerry said that McCain agreed with him. Bush just about lost it - he was obviously mad. Prior to that, McCain would be on different TV news shows and even TDS, knocking Bush in so many words. After that debate, John McCain was on Bush's campaign helicopter - Bush snapped some kind of choke collar on McCain - he was a totally different person after Kerry pissed Commander CooCoo Bananas off by saying McCain agreed with him.
I'd love to know what Rove knows about McLame.
July 20, 2008 5:17 PM | Reply | Permalink
Great post. Rec'd.
As an independent, I would have voted for McCain in 2000. Shudder.
I believe that his 'evolution' from then to now is not all that simplistic. This McCain was always there, waiting to be unwrapped. Layer by layer.
What I really want to know is who is he truly 'dancing' for now?
July 20, 2008 7:23 PM | Reply | Permalink
McCain has kowtowed to the Right on certain issues -- e.g. Bush's tax cuts.
But I think the hawkishness is real, and comes from the heart, and was always there, even in 2000. It's just that in the present int'l environment it's a lot more visible, and more obviously dangerous, than it was in 2000.
July 20, 2008 10:18 PM | Reply | Permalink
Ok, this is slightly off topic, but can someone explain to me why this well written post has 18 recs and appears nowhere on the Recommended Users Post list, yet a blatant troll-bait post which was written immediately after this one and only has 3 recs to its credit is now on that list?
Seriously, why do we even have promoted user posts at this point? TPM's algorithm is so off as to be criminal.
Good job Ben, thanks.
July 21, 2008 8:18 AM | Reply | Permalink