« Time To Get To Work On FISA | hrebendorf's Blog | What Do You WANT To Believe? »

CFTC Quietly Reclassifies Oil Futures Traders


A recent data revision by the Commodities Futures Trading Commission has revised upward--by nearly 25%--the the total number of oil futures contracts thought to be held by speculators.  According to the CFTC, as of July 15, speculators controlled 48% of the crude oil futures markets rather than the 38% they previously reported.  This is a major revision, which will likely change the way analysts and investors view recent moves in the market.  

In reclassifying investments from commercial hedging positions to noncommercial speculative positions, the CFTC has said little about the reasons behind the shift.  But the real surprise in the new numbers is that only one investor was reclassified-meaning that it appears that a single investor controlled 460 million barrels in market positions, or fully 10% of the market.  CFTC officials are not saying who that single investor is, but the recent fall in oil prices coincides fairly closely with the collapse of SemGroup LP, an energy trader which filed for bankruptcy on July 22 after losing $3.2 billion in oil futures and derivatives investments.  Here's a report from The Financial Times:

http://www.financialweek.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20080805/REG/402387333/1036

Another one from the Dow Jones newswire:

http://www.cattlenetwork.com/content.asp?contentid=238244


And here's the raw data:

http://www.cftc.gov/marketreports/commitmentsoftraders/index.htm

14 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Sorry, gave the wrong attribution for the first link. Should have been Financial Week. And here's a clickable link to the second piece:

http://www.cattlenetwork.com/content.asp?contentid=238244

user-pic

SemGroup, eh? I'd have guessed Goldman.

user-pic

As I recall, the WSJ noted that lawmakers asked the Commodity Futures Trading Commission to reclassify swaps dealers as speculators, even though they act directly for commercial hedgers like United Airlines. WSJ said that reclassification inflated the percentage of speculators from under 40% to 70%, which sounds in the range of the 25% increase you mention.

user-pic

The interesting point, I think, is that the CFTC reclassified using the criteria of investors with no other interest in the commodities markets. Which is why the finger is pointing at SemGroup. They had no other investments. Just oil.

This is starting to look like the Hunt brothers all over again.

user-pic

Oh, and they only reclassified ONE investor. Which they haven't named. Not a minor point. Check out the raw data. Very interesting.

Where have you BEEN, BunKitty? I've missed you!

Ditto.

user-pic

Thanks guys. I've missed you too. Been to the desert on a horse with no name. Prolly going back.

Don't stay away so long this time. This place just doesn't have the same, "Oh, Snap!" without you.

hrebendorf and Donal -
you were both part of a prior discussion about a potential bubble in the oil commodities markets. Care to weigh in again?

Based on recent changes, I'd have to say the monkey thought twas all in fun... POP!

user-pic

I don't remember the discussion. Care to refresh my memory?

user-pic

I'll let Jerome a Paris answer:

In fact, in the past month, there was a succession of news that all went in the same direction. In the same week, Bernanke was extremely bearish on the economy, oil stocks were higher than expected, and talks with Iran happened. Each of these took about 3-4% each from the price of oil, bring the price down by more than $15 in 3 days.

And any time this happens, speculators are wrong footed and they need to close out their positions, which usually reinforces temporarily the underlying movement (haha! so there are speculators! And they push prices around! Well, yes, there are speculators - but, for the most part, they follow the market rather than driving it. Any price overshoot is usually temporary. And they do provide valuable services, by bringing in liquidity to prices - and by providing willing counterparties to those that want to buy hedges - you know, like airlines that buy futures or options for their supply over the next few months or quarters at prices to protect themselves - and their fares - from yet higher prices).

http://www.eurotrib.com/story/2008/8/7/18530/14118

user-pic

Does anyone have any insights on the Liberty Crude Oil Pipeline or SemGroup's tie to the Carlyle Group?

I live in Sem Group's hometown and I suspected they were involved in something fishy. I noticed the proximity of the company's collapse and the drop in oil prices, too, and have been meaning to explore it further. Thanks for this post, bunkitty. Rec'd

Leave a comment

hrebendorf

user-pic

Following: 32
Followers: 45

Posts
Comments & Recommends


  • Politics What. Ever.

Favorites

  • Favorite Blogs TPM, Huffpost, Angry Chicken, Not Even Wrong, anArchitecture, BLDGBLOG, orriettacat (JamFancy), GHDB, Schneier On Security, masondixonknitting.com, jwz.org, Super Colossal, doxpara, supereggplant.com (I share Mariko's pen obsession)
  • Favorite Books Lyrics by Oscar Hammerstein II, The Intelligent Investor by Benjamin Graham, Lord Krishna's Cuisine by Yamuna Devi, Japanese Cooking: A Simple Art by Shizuo Tsuji, Strunk and White, Kernighan and Richie
  • Favorite Quotes "Complaining is silly. Either act or forget." - Stefan Sagmeister

Bio

I've spent the last thirty years of my life hitchhiking, hopping freights and driving, driving, driving across America. Currently stuck in Minneapolis, but it's a temporary ailment. Next stop? Gay Paree.

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address