A Bit of Optimism Best Expressed Before I Come To My Senses
Ah, our financial meltdown. Could any crisis be better contrived and timed to elicit every unbecoming, cut-off-your-nose, dig-your-own-grave tendency in our national character?
It bodes not well.
However, such crises also seem to produce their own opportunities for redemption. Opportunities like anti-matter in a crap-strewn universe, and every bit as elusive.
We'll get to that in a moment. But first, let's spend some time on the ledge.
Collected in the window frame behind us, quietly chanting "jump, jump, jump," is every negative influence ever isolated in the laboratories of self-help science. Fear. Fury. Bewilderment. Vindictiveness. Selfishness. Hate. All the impulses we should strive to hold at bay when it's time to make life-or-death decisions.
Evidence that our most rash and counterproductive urges threaten to win the day is everywhere. The blogs are alight with cries of "let them fail!" Never mind that the "they" in question are holding your retirement.
In the recent Senate hearings on the crisis, Senator Sherrod Brown informed Treasury Secretary Paulson that not one of the torrent of calls to the Senator's office was in favor of the bailout plan. I suppose we should be pleased that looming disaster has rekindled America's moribund interest in civic affairs. Thanks to all those who paused their Wii's long enough to contact their representatives. But too bad our idea of constructive criticism is a collective wail of hysteria.
Garbage in, garbage out, says an old rule of thumb, meaning bad information produces faulty conclusions. And in the political sphere, our national hissy-fit ensures that we'll get more fluff than substance from the legislative sausage grinder. For example, capping Wall St. salaries is about as important right now as turning off the bedroom lights before fleeing a house fire.
Anyway, relax, I say. We'll all be taking a pay cut soon enough.
This is the allure of all our worst instincts on display. How do we respond? Do we boldly push them away? Do we resist their corrosive attraction? Of course not. We drink them down like shipwrecked sailors gorging themselves on salt water.
Stupid, stupid us. In penny romances, there is a moment when the protagonist recognizes their mistakes, is filled with regret, and sets out to make all well. They've traveled through a dark tunnel but come out to light.
Life is not like that. In real life, we come not to the tunnel's opening, but to a dead end where we realize we're inhabiting a disaster. But before we can set anything to right, we must first hack our way back through the recent track of our own dysfunction, blaming everyone but ourselves, lashing out indiscriminately, and sowing every bit as much misery and pain on the way out as we did on the way in.
Aren't we delightful?
So the question is, where on this trek are we right now? For several years now, polls have shown that most Americans think the country is heading in the wrong direction. Perhaps then it doesn't require rose-tinted glasses to think this economic collapse is more of a final comeuppance than a wake-up call.
One other observation justifies optimism. I believe that there is an almost Newtonian physics to two-party politics. That a period of anomalous extremism can involuntarily generate its own antithesis. That out of the reeking, toxic decay of Republican depravity is coming some kind of exotic, mysterious particle of unsuspected positive potential. And its name is Barack Obama.
Look, I have no illusions about what the reality of an Obama administration is likely to be. In all likelihood he will be beaten to a political pulp by the problems he will inherit and will forever be tethered to Jimmy Carter in the revisionist worldview of the 12 consecutive Republican administrations his disastrous tenure will ensure. And who knows what unexpected failings of character he will display. He's as human as the rest of us, and if you think I have an inflated opinion of humanity, well, you haven't been reading very carefully.
And yet one can hardly deny that he is a very different quantity than any candidate to come to the brink of the Presidency in the last 40-odd years. And that his viability is a product of our 8-year-long national catastrophe.
Were it not for the lies, the pointless war, the corruption, the disdain for competence, the indefensible use of torture, the disregard for the rule of law and constitutional democracy, and now this great hundred-year-flood of our financial system, is there any chance we would be on the verge of electing a black man whose middle name is "Hussein" President right now? Any chance?
Impossible.
So I think something different is about to happen. Something special. We are on a cusp that has the potential to be transformational, rather than just a slow, dreary crawl back to mediocrity. And it's happening not in spite of the calamity that envelops us, but because of it.
This slime-covered post was found in the sink-strainer when we did the dishes yesterday at Only Sayin'
It bodes not well.
However, such crises also seem to produce their own opportunities for redemption. Opportunities like anti-matter in a crap-strewn universe, and every bit as elusive.
We'll get to that in a moment. But first, let's spend some time on the ledge.
Collected in the window frame behind us, quietly chanting "jump, jump, jump," is every negative influence ever isolated in the laboratories of self-help science. Fear. Fury. Bewilderment. Vindictiveness. Selfishness. Hate. All the impulses we should strive to hold at bay when it's time to make life-or-death decisions.
Evidence that our most rash and counterproductive urges threaten to win the day is everywhere. The blogs are alight with cries of "let them fail!" Never mind that the "they" in question are holding your retirement.
In the recent Senate hearings on the crisis, Senator Sherrod Brown informed Treasury Secretary Paulson that not one of the torrent of calls to the Senator's office was in favor of the bailout plan. I suppose we should be pleased that looming disaster has rekindled America's moribund interest in civic affairs. Thanks to all those who paused their Wii's long enough to contact their representatives. But too bad our idea of constructive criticism is a collective wail of hysteria.
Garbage in, garbage out, says an old rule of thumb, meaning bad information produces faulty conclusions. And in the political sphere, our national hissy-fit ensures that we'll get more fluff than substance from the legislative sausage grinder. For example, capping Wall St. salaries is about as important right now as turning off the bedroom lights before fleeing a house fire.
Anyway, relax, I say. We'll all be taking a pay cut soon enough.
This is the allure of all our worst instincts on display. How do we respond? Do we boldly push them away? Do we resist their corrosive attraction? Of course not. We drink them down like shipwrecked sailors gorging themselves on salt water.
Stupid, stupid us. In penny romances, there is a moment when the protagonist recognizes their mistakes, is filled with regret, and sets out to make all well. They've traveled through a dark tunnel but come out to light.
Life is not like that. In real life, we come not to the tunnel's opening, but to a dead end where we realize we're inhabiting a disaster. But before we can set anything to right, we must first hack our way back through the recent track of our own dysfunction, blaming everyone but ourselves, lashing out indiscriminately, and sowing every bit as much misery and pain on the way out as we did on the way in.
Aren't we delightful?
So the question is, where on this trek are we right now? For several years now, polls have shown that most Americans think the country is heading in the wrong direction. Perhaps then it doesn't require rose-tinted glasses to think this economic collapse is more of a final comeuppance than a wake-up call.
One other observation justifies optimism. I believe that there is an almost Newtonian physics to two-party politics. That a period of anomalous extremism can involuntarily generate its own antithesis. That out of the reeking, toxic decay of Republican depravity is coming some kind of exotic, mysterious particle of unsuspected positive potential. And its name is Barack Obama.
Look, I have no illusions about what the reality of an Obama administration is likely to be. In all likelihood he will be beaten to a political pulp by the problems he will inherit and will forever be tethered to Jimmy Carter in the revisionist worldview of the 12 consecutive Republican administrations his disastrous tenure will ensure. And who knows what unexpected failings of character he will display. He's as human as the rest of us, and if you think I have an inflated opinion of humanity, well, you haven't been reading very carefully.
And yet one can hardly deny that he is a very different quantity than any candidate to come to the brink of the Presidency in the last 40-odd years. And that his viability is a product of our 8-year-long national catastrophe.
Were it not for the lies, the pointless war, the corruption, the disdain for competence, the indefensible use of torture, the disregard for the rule of law and constitutional democracy, and now this great hundred-year-flood of our financial system, is there any chance we would be on the verge of electing a black man whose middle name is "Hussein" President right now? Any chance?
Impossible.
So I think something different is about to happen. Something special. We are on a cusp that has the potential to be transformational, rather than just a slow, dreary crawl back to mediocrity. And it's happening not in spite of the calamity that envelops us, but because of it.
This slime-covered post was found in the sink-strainer when we did the dishes yesterday at Only Sayin'
Advertisement





Really good piece. Rec'd strongly.
September 29, 2008 1:09 PM | Reply | Permalink
Excellent post. Entertainingly (?) written. The combination of despair and hope mirrors what I'm feeling.
To watch the behavior of Republicans through all of this is mind-boggling: at no point do any of them, to a man, feel the least bit of responsibility for not just their actions, but their ideology that has been nothing but a disaster. You would think some amount of civic responsibility would kick in. For a few of them, at least. It is breathtaking to me that they are so stupid or so blinded or so corrupt down to their cores that there isn't even one small voice from the Republican side saying, "Shit. This doesn't work."
The foundation of Obama's message is a belief that smart and good should prevail, and his trust that those qualities abide in us as a people. It's the civic-minded patriotism that I was taught as a child -- a love for the Constitution and what it can accomplish for the good of humanity if we take principled personal responsibility and contribute to the greater good. Our nation is as good as the individuals who contribute to it and nurture it. The Enlightenment.
So I'm hopeful, too. At 58 years old, I have no illusions about the bloody mess Obama will inherit and any one person's ability to solve our problems. But I fervently hope that we'll start to take the steps to a constructive patriotism again because of his leadership.
Maybe even one or two Republicans will even say "I apologize".
Hopeful I am.
September 30, 2008 2:43 AM | Reply | Permalink
Sorry, but... This "The night is darkest just before the dawn..." etc. optimism sounds a bit like Condi Rice's blather about "the Chinese word for crisis is danger + opportunity"; which she trotted out years ago to explain why things in Irag were going Just Great.
Just Sayin'
September 30, 2008 6:22 AM | Reply | Permalink
I doubt there's really anything we can do to slow the train wreck to be honest. That point was passed in 2004. I'm in favor of throwing pitiful handfuls of good money after the bad, simply because I loathe to be throwing up my hands. However, I've reached that nirvana state of mind where I'm resigned to sitting back and watching the Supernova. Even unfolding catastrophes can be fascinating to witness, and beauty is a strange fruit.
September 30, 2008 7:22 AM | Reply | Permalink
What kind of dishes are you washing?
September 30, 2008 8:00 AM | Reply | Permalink
It is not that Americans are unclear about the risk to their savings, but that they were completely unpersuaded by the lousy deal being offered, the extortionate tone to the plea to save investment banks.
It is the fault of Americans that their government has been cryin wolf about nothing, (see Iraq, Social Security), while ignoring the obvious challenges? (See oil, climate, dead soldiers, dragging economy, corrupt justice, sleazy lobbying, ruined national reputation.)
September 30, 2008 9:15 AM | Reply | Permalink
Is it Nov. 4th yet?
Seriously, this is going to be a weird 34 days.
September 30, 2008 10:35 AM | Reply | Permalink
You got that right. Neck braces all around. The whiplash-inducing storm of cognitive dissonance is upon us, and we're not in the eye of it yet.
September 30, 2008 12:10 PM | Reply | Permalink