« Hillary is Not a Pitbull with Lipstick | Desidero's Blog | Don't Just Sit There: Advertise!!! Personal Political Ads »
Poppies: Who Controls Our Votes and Minds?
Pay attention now. Because over the next week we might see a bit of sleight of hand, as the press decides that Sarah Palin is really too much and that McCain's halo has tarnished. Pay attention. Because will that really be the way the process goes, will that really be their way of forming a decision? Is the press really assessing public opinion, or simply mapping its own new narratives onto the popular scene and making its own presumptions seem like "reality"? And is there an ulterior force(s) behind that presumption?
Ever since Eric Boehlert wrote his nice little expose on shared suspended disbelief of reality I've been waiting to see which blogs left and right would pick up on the phenomenon - the self-pleasing ability to jointly ignore huge swaths of obvious documented fact to collectively adopt a contrary opinion. Psychological studies show that well-educated people perversely are better able to use their IQ's to adopt positions unsupported by facts. And recent studies show the larger the social group, the more intelligent the species of ape. So here we display a group participatory ability at self-delusion encompassing millions at a time (not that this is a fair study - lower primates don't have TV & internet to work with).
But here's the problem. When working with groups this large and influences this complex, it becomes difficult to say whether we deluded ourselves, or whether someone deluded us instead, figuring out which buttons to press to make us think we were turning that remote-controlled car?
Because as Boehlert points out, the press, the Democrats and basically all of us assumed a patronizingly untrue version of reality to drive through a particular view of reality and subsequent "obvious" result. And Democrats are supposed to be the less media-savvy - Republicans are the "manipulative ones". And the press is supposedly "free" and "independent", even as the come across so repetitive, mimicking each other with the same catch phrases and press release soundbites so they look more like chorus girl dancers and Gregorian chanters than free thinkers and analysts.
So what's the mechanism at play when Mark Halperin suddenly wakes up after several years of extreme R.E.M. sleep and notices that Republicans lie profoundly and obviously about just about everything when they get on TV or the campaign stump (including an impressive coordinated perversion of reality we call "spin", though it would be less impressive if there were less willful suspension of belief amongst the audience)? And that McCain and Palin are indeed true to this perverted Republicanism. Is Mark Halperin just a lone clairvoyant Rumpelstilskin? Or has 100 years passed for Sleeping Beauty's kingdom and Obama is our prince? Or is it just another fairy tale, where the wicked witch ensconced in yonder dark castle is peering yet again into her magic crystal ball, ready to unleash her flying monkeys on a new attack, or to put the kingdom aslumber anew, with slightly different dreams but similar results, whispering "sleep, poppies, sleep, poppies, sleep...."
In short, who's in control here? And why exactly did we think *WE* were?
Advertisement





The witch is displaced by water. The power lies in OZ. Not the man behind the curtain, for he holds no real power. He plays with all the gadgets and sweats enough to kill the witch but is still useless. The true power of the Wizard is the idea of a greater force capable of taking care of us when we have no heart, no courage, no brain. Bring on the little girl with the stolen red shoes and there you have it. The Wizard will take us all home in a big balloon. Toto, Auntie Em ... can we find our brain, our courage, our heart without losing our soul? Our country depends on it.
Clicking my heels together and hoping we get it right this time. There's no place like home.
September 11, 2008 6:41 AM | Reply | Permalink
Did I hear something about monkeys?
September 11, 2008 8:40 AM | Reply | Permalink
Even weirder, someone did a post on flying monkeys just after this one. I'm waiting for McCain to take out a hit on blue dudes. None of us are safe.
September 11, 2008 9:33 AM | Reply | Permalink
Rec'd, because the post is very eloquent about how strange it feels to be a social animal. Who exactly *is* in control? Why do people all go to sleep, sometimes, and then all wake up at once?
I think this is one fight where the media is on our side -- as much as the structure of the news business will allow them to be. First of all because our cause is just, and secondly because McCain is displaying the same contempt for journalism that Bush has displayed for eight years -- and they're personally sick of it.
The question that remains is whether it really matters that the journalists know your side is telling the truth, and the other side isn't. The jury, I think, is still out. For one thing, as Josh and others have been saying, occasional fact-checking isn't enough to stop determined liars.
But maybe even more importantly, many swing voters don't watch a lot of news. They really do form their opinions, as Rick Davis says, by getting an overall impression of the candidates as people, rather than attending to their records or positions on the issues.
I think we've got ways to reach those people -- ads, Letterman appearances, canvassing, and so on. But it may depend on our donations and labor, more than it depends on Mark Halperin.
September 11, 2008 9:33 AM | Reply | Permalink
This so funny, Des. A very wordy and poetic description of...wait for it...spin.
Are you, by chance, a University Professor - in the social sciences, perhaps?
September 11, 2008 11:12 AM | Reply | Permalink
Nope, studying hard to be a blowhard politician. Methinks I've almost got it. In time to retire perhaps.
September 11, 2008 2:28 PM | Reply | Permalink
Nah, ah - too much intellect to make it as a pol.
You'd make a great pundit, though. :)
September 12, 2008 3:50 PM | Reply | Permalink
Waking up from our self-induced torpor requires a superhuman effort. In fact, it's so massive that most people simply refuse to attempt it. Our primitive, reptilian mind simultaneously informs and poisons our intellect. It makes us do things we don't understand. As Clotaire Rapaille, author of The Culture Code has said, "I don't care what you're going to tell me intellectually. I don't care. Why? Because the reptilian always wins. My experience is that most of the time, people have no idea why they're doing what they're doing. They have no idea. So they're going to try to make up something that makes sense. Why do you need a Hummer to go shopping? 'Well, you know, in case I need to go off road.'"
We have no idea why we're doing what we're doing. And unless we're willing to make the effort to rip the weeds out of the garden of our mind the moment they appear, we never will. Don't look to the human race to do this any time soon. It's simply too difficult. Most human beings will die in their ignorance. They might as well be chickens.
http://archive.salon.com/books/int/2006/05/20/rapaille/index.html
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/persuaders/interviews/rapaille.html
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/persuaders/interviews/luntz.html
September 11, 2008 11:47 PM | Reply | Permalink
O brother.
Well, perfessor, it sounds awful fancy, alright, but it sure doesn't make any sense.
September 12, 2008 1:24 AM | Reply | Permalink
Well, I wrote a longish comment here, but it appears to have been tucked away in the TPM safe. Which they seem to be doing more & more. Donno. I said something about birds, and how they can see in the ultraviolet. Probably shouldn't have said that.
Oh yeah. There were tunes. I'll see if I can sneak this one through. Peter Gabriel and Karl Wallinger (from World Party & Waterboys), recording spontaneous, over years, with lots of people passing through. Love this first one - Big Blue Ball.
September 12, 2008 4:24 AM | Reply | Permalink