« You Gotta Hand It To Palin | Arch Stanton's Blog | What A Useless Debate »

These Moderators


I think that the moderators in these past two debates have been mediocre at best.  The McCain attack on tough questioning has turned what should be a tough interview into a series of interspersed stump speeches where both candidates have been allowed to dictate the discussion, to everybody's detriment.  If I went in to a job interview, and told the interviewer that I wasn't going to answer his question I would be immediately rejected for that job.

These tickets have become so studded with hero worship and cushy bipartisanship that the moderators seem to be sitting in admiration rather than providing the harsh scrutiny that's needed to dig deeper than the rhetoric.  This has allowed both candidates to stick strictly to their talking points and has not addressed anything but poise and ability to speak.  If a candidate doesn't answer a question you don't move on, you keep asking the question again and again until they answer it.  It lacks any good journalism.  Nothing has been revealed about these candidates that we didn't already know, it provides no incite but what the campaign wants us to believe.

I'm not suggesting that the moderator should be bullying the candidates into a corner, the candidates should be doing that to each other, but when they aren't it's the moderators job to keep picking at the truth until its revealed.

1 Comment

| Leave a comment

"I'm not suggesting that the moderator should be bullying the candidates into a corner, the candidates should be doing that to each other, but when they aren't it's the moderators job to keep picking at the truth until its revealed."

I disagree. You're right, the candidates should be doing that to each other, but the moderator has no responsibility to do the candidate's job for them. Anyway, had Gwen called Biden or Palin out on mistakes they made, not only would it had wasted time to cover more policy questions and would lead to he-said she-said arguments, but it would give Palin an excuse to blame the moderator for bias.

Leave a comment

Arch Stanton

user-pic

Following:
Followers:

Posts
Comments & Recommends


Favorites

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address