A smaller government is a better government has been the mantra from the right for a very long time. But in the wake of hurricane Katrina that fallacy has been exposed. More important then a small government is having a responsive, effective government. To have a responsive, effective government we need to most competent people in the country to lead government. Bush and the conservatives want to see our government operate more like a major corporation. But as Friedman notes, that is not the case.
That is certainly the sense I got after observing the Katrina debacle from half a world away here in Singapore - a city-state that, if it believes in anything, believes in good governance. It may roll up the sidewalks pretty early here, and it may even fine you if you spit out your gum, but if you had to choose anywhere in Asia you would want to be caught in a typhoon, it would be Singapore. Trust me, the head of Civil Defense here is not simply someone's college roommate.
The corruption of cronyism has infected the body politick to the point debilitation. This didn't happen overnight. This infection festered and grew worse without the American people even noticing. And removing Michael Brown from FEMA is not a cure, it is just suppressing the symptoms of the disease. The operations of our government is has been plagued by political hacks for the last 5 years. Combine unqualified political hacks with the conservative's zealot campaign to "starve the beast" has compromised our government to the point of being completely ineffective. All the conservatives have accomplished is letting the GOP supporting corporate cash cows feed at the trough of the GOP's version of big government.
The point of compassionate conservatism is that it isn't the government's place to assist others it is the people's responsibility. But compassionate conservatism is fallacy number two. What has happened is a fostering of a "everybody for themselves" attitude in government. The ideals they espouse in their porposed gutting of social security was put into practice in the Gulf post-Katrina. In your time of need don't look to Washington...you are on your own. And time and time again the conservative pundits have claimed that the victims are to blame for not helping themselves, even when they couldn't.
Freidman makes a great point of how we can fix this problem, in veiwing Singapore's government. They pay their leaders over $1,000,000 per year but hold them to the highest standards...
Indeed, Singapore believes so strongly that you have to get the best-qualified and least-corruptible people you can into senior positions in the government, judiciary and civil service that its pays its prime minister a salary of $1.1 million a year. It pays its cabinet ministers and Supreme Court justices just under $1 million a year, and pays judges and senior civil servants handsomely down the line.
And he goes on to say...
"In the areas that are critical to our survival, like Defense, Finance and the Ministry of Home Affairs, we look for the best talent," said Kishore Mahbubani, dean of the Lee Kwan Yew School of Public Policy. "You lose New Orleans, and you have 100 other cities just like it. But we're a city-state. We lose Singapore and there is nothing else. ... [So] the standards of discipline are very high. There is a very high degree of accountability in Singapore."
When a subway tunnel under construction collapsed here in April 2004 and four workers were killed, a government inquiry concluded that top executives of the contracting company should be either fined or jailed.
We should be paying top money to the most highly qualified people to serve in our government and lead our nation. With the increased compensation should come the expectation those leaders should have the highest level of integrity and accountability.
Mediocre people leading the greatest country in the world should be unnacceptable to everyone in the US. And advocating a smaller government with less accountability to the people, in terms of it's societal responsibilities to ensure the welfare of the people (the core of conservatism), will lead to the fall of the US as a true leader in the world.
I think Freidman nailed it this time...
[But] it is not only government that doesn't show up when government is starved of resources and leached of all its meaning. Community doesn't show up either, sacrifice doesn't show up, pulling together doesn't show up, 'we're all in this together' doesn't show up."