Musings of a "real America" expat.
"We believe that the best of America is in these small towns that we get to visit, and in these wonderful little pockets of what I call the real America, being here with all of you hard-working, very patriotic, very pro-America areas of this great nation." Sarah Palin
I've been listening to this constant drumbeat from McCain and Palin and their surrogates about who's a "real American" vs. who's a "fake American" and I have to confess that as someone who spent the first twenty-plus years of my life as a "real American" and the last twenty as a "fake American," I'm suffering from a little bit of an identity crisis right now. Sarah Palin's comment was just the beginning. Last week, a Republican congresswoman called for an investigation into which members of Congress are "anti-American." (Didn't Joe McCarthy ferret them all out about fifty years ago?) This was followed by a North Carolina congressman who was introducing John McCain at a rally and said that "liberals hate real Americans." Then, when asked why McCain is trailing Obama in Virginia polls, a McCain spokesperson said that McCain had strong support in "real Virginia," which I'm guessing is a commonwealth in "real America." And when you consider that "Joe the Plumber" has become the official McCain/Palin mascot, you realize that the McCain/Palin home-stretch strategy isn't all that complicated. McCain/Palin are holding themselves out as the ticket of church-going, blue-collar folks from small towns in red states who are the "real Americans." Obama/Biden represent the elitist, educated, white-collar, big city types who are all obviously "fake Americans."
Well, being a native-born citizen of "real America" and a naturalized citizen of "fake America," I have a few thoughts on this subject. I established my "real American" bona fides growing up in a mining town in Montana. As a kid, my next-door neighbor across the alley was a copper mine. And when that mine was shut down and abandoned, it became our neighborhood playground. Both of my grandfathers and my dad worked in the mines. Nobody before my generation went to college unless they were going to become a priest. I went to a Catholic high school and helped pay my way through a state college as a sewer worker. John McCain and Sarah Palin think "Joe the Plumber" embodies blue-collar "real America"? I was "Joe the Sewer Worker" in a freakin' mining town in Montana. And when you hear Sarah Palin extol the virtues of "Joe Six-Pack" because apparently being a hard drinker makes you a better American? Before I quit drinking, I was "Joe Wild Turkey with a Twelve-Pack Chaser" which was, after all, why I eventually quit drinking. So I guess in my drinking days I was "Captain America." Funny thing, though -- I didn't even realize I was being patriotic at the time. I was just trying to get loaded.
But here's the thing. With the help, support, and encouragement (read: "threats") of my blue-collar Irish Catholic parents, my five blue-collar Irish Catholic siblings and I all earned college degrees, and a few of us went on to earn advanced degrees. But you know, despite all that book learnin', it never occurred to any of us that our parents' were only sending us to college to secretly subvert the small town, blue-collar, "real American" values of their kids. Until McCain and Palin opened my eyes, I always thought that my parents sacrificed so much because they wanted their kids to do just a little bit better -- educationally and economically -- than they did. Maybe I'm just naive, but I always kind of thought that was a cornerstone of the American dream.
And chalk this up to a lack of introspection on my part, but when I was practicing law in the latte-sipping Babylon of Portland, Oregon, I didn't feel like I was less of an American than when I was throwing back boilermakers in a blue-collar bar at the end of my shift at the local sewer utility. Even today, when I'm sitting in the pews at Mass, I don't feel like I'm more of an American than some of my friends who choose to sit in other pews or no pews at all. With the possible exception of the multiple novenas I'm starting nine days before election day, I've always felt like my relationship with God had nothing to do with being an American -- real or fake.
So here's an idea and I think it's just crazy enough to work. Until we can officially divide "real America" from "fake America," and institute some kind of visa program that limits the amount of time big city kids can visit their small town parents before being deported, maybe we can put the division of our country on hold. I've got to believe there will be plenty of time to split up the country and turn families against each other based on arbitrary divisions after the election's over. So maybe we could back-burner the whole "real American" vs. "fake American" thing and focus instead on figuring out why ninety percent of us are "depressed Americans." Now, I know we're going to need some sort of trivial distraction to take people's minds off of the impending civil war so I was thinking -- and I'm just spitballing here -- how about the economy? Yeah, I'm pretty sure I heard there was something going on with the economy in this country.




